View Single Post
Old 11-28-2007, 01:25 PM   #14 (permalink)
DickHardman
Master
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 4,055
DickHardman is a jewel in the roughDickHardman is a jewel in the roughDickHardman is a jewel in the roughDickHardman is a jewel in the rough
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by dredd1990 View Post
Truth about judo. of course size and strength matter, but at 200 lbs, your a-ok for almost any MA type. you'd be a powerhouse. if i were you i'd focus on grappling and bone breaking techniques if your were goin for full contact sport. dont actually break the target's bones. put pressure, just let them knwo that you could... demoralizes them. and also, you could certianly do Judo. but.. personally for me, u said u wanted to use it as a sport and defense. im an instructor at my dojo. dojo is a special word in my knowledge, its a school, and therefore you must submit an application for us to accept you. you can not flash cash and walk in. thats not how it works here. in many applications people have said " i want to take (insert MA here) for sport and to get into shape.) every application i recieve marked as this, i promptly reply with a no. martial arts are not to use for sport... thats not the true meaning of it. its to teach self discipline, build confidence, exert stress, and become harmonious with yourself. but. there are times when a fight is imminent. and in these times, you wouldnt want to handle it as a sport... unless of course your using the brazillian style, Capoeira.... then go for it... but, i digress... you dont want to be playign with an attacker like its a sport, you want to protect yourself, and leave them no slack, give them chances to leave or flee, but if they proceed to try and fight you. dessimate, dessicrate, and destroy them. no mercy for the wicked. judo would certainly help you ascertain victory. but if your just going for sport, stick with the gym and free weights. if your realy interested in Martial Arts. take it for what it is. the power to be lethal. the power to survive. dont let this callous reply stop you my friend, if you still want to pursue judo or any martial arts. go for it. im a bit of an extremist for martial arts anyways. but please remember. when trained in the martial science your being trained to kill.
~Strick~
i agree that martial arts should be about self defense and not sport, however straining some stuff in a sportive manner can develope and cultivate vital attributes that are great for real life self defense situations, and they also give practitioners a proven delivery system that can act as a catalyst for all the nastier techniques and strategies that are not found in sport arts.

for example, a martial artist serious about self defense can still train in western boxing to develop faster reflexes, better footwork, harder punches, etc and integrate it into what he has learned from other sources and arts. boxing can also provide a good delivery system for things you learned in other arts. for example you could use the footwork and counterattacking/parrying skills of boxing to parry an attackers strike which would open him up to something nastier like an knifehand strike to his neck or throat, or an upward palms strike to his chin etc......

sport arts have a lot of value for self defense if you have the proper mindset and know what to look for.
DickHardman is offline   Reply With Quote