brokenelbow

So what is the point of improving your technique ever so slightly over 5 to 6 years? What technique are you spending so much time working on?

__________________
The crap that many schools do is not the crap I was taught or train in or teach.

Damnit... it made sense when it was running through my head.

DM

bbbb

Our top belt is a red belt. They only give 5 degrees aswell.

The Sihing's wear the black belt over their red belt as a symbol of being humble.

Only the Master and Grandmaster can be awarded higher. I'm not arguing. He made it. (SiJowe aswell as SiGung.).!!

__________________
Use attack as your indestructable spiritual strength.
Awareness is the spirit.
Attack is the foundation of thought.
Attack like thunder from the heaven's.
Retreat like dust of the earth.

robertlee

It used to take from 3 to 5 years for shodan. Then 2 more years to make nidan then 2 more years for sandan. Then 3 more years for yondan then 3 more for godan. After that it was time and effert as many styles have no set requirrements after yondan. But As have said over the past 12 or so years. I have seen several places that have promoted rank fast. And to me they handed it out For money not for what was earned. Also used to be if you was less then 16 years old you recieved a junior black belt and had to retest after you turned 16. We have 5 year old blackbelts out there now. When people get more down to not giving rank away . Then a blackbelt will represent more. A black does not mean you are a better fighter. It means you have pasted the required level of training For that style. I would hope a blackbelt in a style could out perform the lower belts in there school. But as proven many times learning the tools and being able to use the tools That takes some training to Like I was told over 30 years ago. If a person could just master the tools that is learned to just become a green belt they would be able to fight very well. And some of the better tools are learned after a first degrwee blakbelt ranking. Kind of like saving the best for last. But if given at earlyer training levels how much better would a person be After they had much more training time in developing the use of there tools. Its proven over and over a large amount of tools takes much longer to get good at. And many will never be needed in combat. As fighting is short fast and down to the getting it done and over. What you have is a short time to be effective. And thats use of common tools that work and have been tested. So a blackbelt is time and training. but a fighter is takeing the time to train to fight

__________________
r.lee

kwai chang pain

I think robertlee makes some good points. A low ranking black belt (1st dan, some even have "zero" dan) symbolizes mastery of the basics. Beyond that you could argue the dans/degrees are steps toward becoming a master. For a lot of styles that is 5th dan.

IMHO what black belt REALLY SHOULD represent is someone who can dish it out and who can take it. It's unfortunate that rank is such a joke at soooo many schools. If you want to really BE a black belt, you damn well better have tested yourself.

I got 2nd dan in one style, but I didn't want to go on because I didn't think going onto 3rd would really improve me. Plus, there's always politics and the almighty dollar along with it. Now I'm basically one of those "masterless samurai's".

__________________
May your knuckles always drip with the blood of your enemies.

Balrog

Not necessarily.

In the Songahm style, taught by ATA, everybody tests for rank. When the founder of ATA, H. U. Lee, was elevated to Grand Master, he brought in ranking and recognized Grand Masters from other styles and tested in public before them and all of the Songahm students that were present (I was one of them). Upon his death, S. H. Lee became the Grand Master and did the same thing.

GM H. U. Lee's philosophy was that, regardless of rank, we are all students. I was present at a regional testing where he was the guest judge. Just before the testing, a young white belt kid asked him, "Sir, who teaches you?". GM Lee replied, "You do!".

GQchris

I like what Bruce said about belts, that they were good for holding up pants... it matters more that the man be able to actually fight.

__________________
Owner of a lonely heart.. much better than a owner of a broken heart...

totaltwatdeano

__________________
DeanO

Shaolin Bushido

Only a noob would assume every black belt has all those qualities. He would have some experience and that's what I clicked.

__________________
www.eastcoastfighter.com "Supporting MMA by Supporting One Another"

Shaolin Bushido

Some people train in various arts as a vehicle for self perfection ... obviously you have other motivation but it depends on how you were trained. Maybe you train just for self defense or competition but my old teacher would often share stories of him still trying ot perfect the simplest techniques ... after 50 years or so of experience.

__________________
www.eastcoastfighter.com "Supporting MMA by Supporting One Another"

totaltwatdeano

__________________
DeanO

Shaolin Bushido

Thank you.

__________________
www.eastcoastfighter.com "Supporting MMA by Supporting One Another"

Zentenk

Knowledge - of what exactly? I'm pretty sure those 11 year old black belts are very knowledgable.

Skill - Hardly, I've seen some BB that lacked skill, maybe they didn't try hard enough or weren't trained properly.

Experience - They have to go through it so they gain the experience to become a BB.

Fighting Ability - No, some people just aren't born to fight and will always suck even if they are black belts.

kuk sool won

you have to take into account for every rule, there are exceptions, not everything can be measured and put into statisitics. For example some people are rewarded their black belt via reasons of honour, therefore they aren't experienced? Then again, GENERALLY, peoples fighting ability will have gotten better since they had first started training.

__________________

bjjp

well a belt only covers 2 iches of you ass kill covers the rest but it dont matter about the belt it matters about the person the belt is around.thought i would put my two cent worth in.

kuk sool won

from what i can make from that, its basically everyones opinion

__________________