A Black Belt symbolizes - Page 5

kanik · 08-11-2007, 06:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dodgeduckdodge

Now-a-days?

That's what black belt meant when it first came into popular use, back in the late 1920's. Nothing has changed except people's fantastic ideas of what black belt means to them, and what they think it should mean to others.

Alcohol

Hmmm... good point, you sure showed me ^_^

dodgeduckdodge · 08-11-2007, 11:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kanik

Hmmm... good point, you sure showed me ^_^

That's what I thought too.

Alcohol

kanik · 08-12-2007, 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dodgeduckdodge

That's what I thought too.

Alcohol

Well I aint gonna try and justify my stupidity, because that would be... well... stupid! All I can say is. Oh damn, there goes me making dumb-ass assumptions again. But seriously, what you said makes perfect sence, good job pulling me up on that. ^_^

wsdddoa012 · 09-02-2007, 01:14 AM

Well since the black belt nowdays seems to mean soo many things to different people, I thought I'd just give my two cents now.

"The only thing the belt is good for is holding your pants up, let's spar shall we?"

Maturity in the arts, and holding your pants up. Seem too complicated? I still say we should go back to the old days when all the students wore a white belt, never washed it and as the years grew the belt became different colors because of the long time of training, green, yellow, brown then after about 20-30 years maybe black. But of course that's up for speculation, I think It's a good concept myself. Tell that to any of my students

BTW: would a loop belt be better then a strap on belt for my size 80 jeans? haha!!!

kanik · 09-02-2007, 06:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wsdddoa012

Well since the black belt nowdays seems to mean soo many things to different people, I thought I'd just give my two cents now.

"The only thing the belt is good for is holding your pants up, let's spar shall we?"

Maturity in the arts, and holding your pants up. Seem too complicated? I still say we should go back to the old days when all the students wore a white belt, never washed it and as the years grew the belt became different colors because of the long time of training, green, yellow, brown then after about 20-30 years maybe black. But of course that's up for speculation, I think It's a good concept myself. Tell that to any of my students

BTW: would a loop belt be better then a strap on belt for my size 80 jeans? haha!!!

Great response! I like that quote!! I also kinda gree with the white belt and never wash thingy too.

dodgeduckdodge · 09-03-2007, 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wsdddoa012

Well since the black belt nowdays seems to mean soo many things to different people, I thought I'd just give my two cents now.

"The only thing the belt is good for is holding your pants up, let's spar shall we?"

Maturity in the arts, and holding your pants up. Seem too complicated? I still say we should go back to the old days when all the students wore a white belt, never washed it and as the years grew the belt became different colors because of the long time of training, green, yellow, brown then after about 20-30 years maybe black. But of course that's up for speculation, I think It's a good concept myself. Tell that to any of my students

BTW: would a loop belt be better then a strap on belt for my size 80 jeans? haha!!!

That is a myth. It never was that way in the "old days".

Jigoro Kano invented the use of the color belt system back in the later 1800's for his Elementary school Judo students. Gichin Funakoshi copied the idea for Karate, then it took off from there. The original colors were white, red and black, the official colors of Japan at that time.

Alcohol

KickNit · 09-27-2007, 01:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shaolin-warrior

That is the beauty of Karate in my eyes. I as a student can set my own bar and my own expectations to either meet or exceed that of my instructor. It is an individual "sport" for lack of a better word. I don't have to worry that the person next to me can't go the distance, my sucesses and failures are based solely on my efforts.

Well, that depends on whether you are involved in competition or not. If so then it isn't so individual after all because the performance of your team mates determines the success of the team. I'd say Karate at its best is an individual sport because I like it one on one. But it can be a team sport.

darrianation · 09-27-2007, 02:13 PM

This has probably already been said but a black belt means to me nothing more than a marketing ploy to dupe the unsuspecting out of their hard earned cash.

Obviously I didn't vote becuase the most correct answer wasn't there.

Mike Brewer · 01-06-2008, 04:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dodgeduckdodge

That is a myth. It never was that way in the "old days".

Jigoro Kano invented the use of the color belt system back in the later 1800's for his Elementary school Judo students. Gichin Funakoshi copied the idea for Karate, then it took off from there. The original colors were white, red and black, the official colors of Japan at that time.

Alcohol

I didn't know that. Kinda cool.

bodhisattva · 01-07-2008, 08:02 AM

I always heard the belt system actually came from an American, post world war. He was teaching Karate in America, something he found during the world wa - and to his surprise he found that Americans want a series of short-term goals as they work towards a long term goal.

the problem was his Karate had two belts - white and black. And he couldn't keep people interested long enough on the journey to black belt (it was too much of a long term goal to hold their interest for long) so he came up with small stair steps on the way to black belt - so the Americans could focus on short term goals.

Even during the time I spent studying Judo, I never heard that Jigoro Kano was the "inventer of the belt system."

But it may well be true, because my story up above is just anecdotal information passed around a classroom that claimed it taught "self-defense" and in reality only taught some weird dance moves that weren't good for self-defense, and weren't much good for dance, either.

--

In answer to your question, what does a black belt symbolize, it depends on the system. In most traditional martial art classes, a black belt signifies that you showed up to class, paid your fees to attend the class, did some movements in the air for hours, learned some semi-acrobatic kicks and self-defense moves that wouldn't work on Grandma.

However, in a BJJ curriculum, the belts are handed out for performance - fighting ability. If you can hang with the blue belts then you will eventually find yourself receiving a blue belt. It's all based on actual fighting performance - and its the only kind of "belt system" I care about.

It's a really, really, really good thing to have a belt system based on performance. People actually learn to fight!

Mike Brewer · 01-07-2008, 09:56 AM

Quote:

...learned some semi-acrobatic kicks and self-defense moves that wouldn't work on Grandma.

Dude, wouldn't that be hysterical if some guy jumped up in the air and did a 540 spinning heel hook right to his grandma's face?! POW! Dentures flying, depends coming undone...God, it'd make YouTube's top ten for sure.

bodhisattva · 01-07-2008, 10:38 AM

It would be funnier if she ducked it, threw him to the ground, and went to stomping..

Huntley · 03-28-2008, 01:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by medic06

What does a black truly symbolize?

To me it's experience.

I'm a 5th Dan but I know I was better as a 3rd or 4th Dan, so I can't say that I'm better than an 18 year old 3rd Dan just skill. And I’m a much better coach at 34 than I was at 18…so experience is my answer.

View Poll Results: A Black Belt represents
knowledge	10	15.87%
skill	5	7.94%
experience	17	26.98%
overall fighting ability	1	1.59%
all of the above	30	47.62%
Voters: 63. You may not vote on this poll

09-02-2007, 01:14 AM	#64 (permalink)
wsdddoa012 Registered User Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 88	black belt response Well since the black belt nowdays seems to mean soo many things to different people, I thought I'd just give my two cents now. "The only thing the belt is good for is holding your pants up, let's spar shall we?" Maturity in the arts, and holding your pants up. Seem too complicated? I still say we should go back to the old days when all the students wore a white belt, never washed it and as the years grew the belt became different colors because of the long time of training, green, yellow, brown then after about 20-30 years maybe black. But of course that's up for speculation, I think It's a good concept myself. Tell that to any of my students BTW: would a loop belt be better then a strap on belt for my size 80 jeans? haha!!! __________________ Mike Senior Chief Instructor

09-27-2007, 02:13 PM	#68 (permalink)
darrianation Registered User Join Date: Feb 2003 Posts: 1,901	This has probably already been said but a black belt means to me nothing more than a marketing ploy to dupe the unsuspecting out of their hard earned cash. Obviously I didn't vote becuase the most correct answer wasn't there. __________________ "Two decades of danger, damage, deviance, and delirium"

01-07-2008, 08:02 AM	#70 (permalink)
bodhisattva Registered User Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: nowhere Posts: 544	Hm. I always heard... I always heard the belt system actually came from an American, post world war. He was teaching Karate in America, something he found during the world wa - and to his surprise he found that Americans want a series of short-term goals as they work towards a long term goal. the problem was his Karate had two belts - white and black. And he couldn't keep people interested long enough on the journey to black belt (it was too much of a long term goal to hold their interest for long) so he came up with small stair steps on the way to black belt - so the Americans could focus on short term goals. Even during the time I spent studying Judo, I never heard that Jigoro Kano was the "inventer of the belt system." But it may well be true, because my story up above is just anecdotal information passed around a classroom that claimed it taught "self-defense" and in reality only taught some weird dance moves that weren't good for self-defense, and weren't much good for dance, either. -- In answer to your question, what does a black belt symbolize, it depends on the system. In most traditional martial art classes, a black belt signifies that you showed up to class, paid your fees to attend the class, did some movements in the air for hours, learned some semi-acrobatic kicks and self-defense moves that wouldn't work on Grandma. However, in a BJJ curriculum, the belts are handed out for performance - fighting ability. If you can hang with the blue belts then you will eventually find yourself receiving a blue belt. It's all based on actual fighting performance - and its the only kind of "belt system" I care about. It's a really, really, really good thing to have a belt system based on performance. People actually learn to fight! __________________ St. Louis MMA Training Club - MMA Boxing / Clinch / Submission Grappling / Wrestling Gym Portland MMA Training Club: MMA Boxing / Brazilian Jiu Jitsu / Greco Roman Wrestling

01-07-2008, 10:38 AM	#72 (permalink)
bodhisattva Registered User Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: nowhere Posts: 544	It would be funnier if she ducked it, threw him to the ground, and went to stomping.. __________________ St. Louis MMA Training Club - MMA Boxing / Clinch / Submission Grappling / Wrestling Gym Portland MMA Training Club: MMA Boxing / Brazilian Jiu Jitsu / Greco Roman Wrestling

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
What does a black belt mean to you?	Hikage	Open Access	11	09-23-2007 12:25 PM
BJJ Black Belt Discrepancies	pstevens	Mixed Martial Arts (MMA) & BJJ Forum	8	06-27-2005 10:51 AM
multiple opponents?	veilmk5	Thaiboxing and Kickboxing	72	05-26-2005 05:39 PM
Meaning of a 'Black Belt'	Nit	Mixed Martial Arts (MMA) & BJJ Forum	8	10-27-2003 11:22 AM
Drunk driver for PRESIDENT!	Mr. Miyagi	Mixed Martial Arts (MMA) & BJJ Forum	35	11-07-2000 07:45 PM