Just wondering if you all consider Tank to be a bully and brawler and Goodridge to be a legit fighter in comparison. I kind of consider them both to be brawlers and bullies who dominate guys that are weaker than them and fall apart and lose heart against tough opponents.
That being said, I think the Big Daddy would have spanked Tank if the two ever would have fought. Daddy's cardio was much better and his skill in striking and wrestling was better too.
Their only common opponents that I can think of offhand was Oleg Taktarov and Predator. They both beat the crap out of Oleg but somehow Tank lost to him. Tank almost beat Don Frye at the time Big Daddy had no chance against Frye, but Tank almost beat a lot of people (including Mo Smith) and almost doesn't count. I wonder if that last Big Daddy-Frye fight was for real or not.
All things considered, I think Big Daddy deserves props for his career and find him to be a much better fighter overall, than Tank.