Whose contributions were greater--West or East?

[Cross_Trainer]

The West has virtually invented modern physical fitness, weight training, plyometrics, and so on. It has also invented boxing (almost an ideal hand art), wrestling, and savate. It has approached MA more 'scientifically' than its eastern counterparts had for centuries--although of course recently they have caught up.

On the other hand, the Eastern martial arts read as almost a who's who of MA styles--Muay Thai, Jujitsu, Karate, Tae Kwon Do, Judo, and so on.

So, although I realize that both are extremely important and interdependent contributions to the MA world, whose has been greater? Has there been any single nation that has made the greatest contributions? Comments?

[Tom Yum]

Originally Posted by Cross_Trainer

The West has virtually invented modern physical fitness, weight training, plyometrics, and so on. It has also invented boxing (almost an ideal hand art), wrestling, and savate. It has approached MA more 'scientifically' than its eastern counterparts had for centuries--although of course recently they have caught up.

On the other hand, the Eastern martial arts read as almost a who's who of MA styles--Muay Thai, Jujitsu, Karate, Tae Kwon Do, Judo, and so on.

So, although I realize that both are extremely important and interdependent contributions to the MA world, whose has been greater? Has there been any single nation that has made the greatest contributions? Comments?

Scientific training methods originated from the former Soviet Union and Eastern Block countries. I would say that certain countries, particularly Holland, Brazil, Japan and former Eastern Block countries seem to produce the best fighters today.

Of course the US, Russia and France have some spectacular fighters as well.

[bvermillion]

Even though this thread has a lot of points that could be argued. Just based on what you have listed there I would have to go with the east.