I'm not trying to argue with anyone I just wanted to throw my two cents into the conversation.
Mixed Martial Arts, Thaiboxing, Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, Combat Submission Wrestling, Jeet Kune Do, Women's Self-Defense, Boxing and Filipino Martial Arts
Well let me say from personal experience that belts don't mean anything. Technically I am still a white belt. And yet when I took BJJ lessons (gi) I tapped three blue belts in my first month. Then after two or so months I rolled for about six minutes with my third degree black belt instructor before locking him in a submission. Due to inexperience I let it go because I wasn't sure if he would have tapped and I didn't want to drain my energy and he escaped and tapped me. We never rolled after that. And he's no push over. I won't mention his name but if you googled it you would get a lot of hits. After that I have worked no-gi only for MMA. The point is that belts don't really matter.
I'm not trying to argue with anyone I just wanted to throw my two cents into the conversation.
i think the belts mean more if you don't mix in the striking and everything else.
Man you guys get a bit frustrating to listen to dudes, why do you call people names who you dont even know, whats the point?
The guy who made a comment about, what you know and do in bjj shows your level. This is true and makes perfect sense, belts dont realy matter its who gives you them. I have a Bjj class down the road from me, which has students from my local area. The blackbelt that jim down the road gives, doesnt mean as much a say Carlos Gracie(rip) now does it. I had my blackbelt when I was young, but looking back I was rubbish. Ive trained or 7 years since then, in various systems and have became far better. The journey to get the belt is more important than the belt, where I train the blackbelt is just he begining. I train lots of bb in vale tudo, and mma, and using their ideas to help me also. Belts are something the west needed to create in order to "rationalize" or compartmentise everything. Traditionaly, the white belt would become dirty over the years, eventualy becoming black. There wer no other belt colours. In china, sifu would sometimes have a gold sash.
There are always braggarts who think themselves clever. They say of other boxing that at one glance they know it. They dont realise that while at one glance they knew it, if they look again they wont know it.
Thats my teachings exactly. I and my students train to fight, to see what works and never exlude anything from possible use. We will not put names to things that do not exist(techniques). Fighting can only be learned from fighting, and belt dont give you that. Some people believe that martial arts is more than fighting or concern themselves with more than fighting, I believe this to be true but fighting is a major component. I think a martial artist can never be complete unless he can deal with conflict. I dont just mean throw some techs and beat the man, it means dealing with the emotions of a sittuation. Ive seen so called experts beaten by a aggressive loose canon. He is not a martial artist but live a warrior life. he lives with the risk, and deals with the concequences.
There are always braggarts who think themselves clever. They say of other boxing that at one glance they know it. They dont realise that while at one glance they knew it, if they look again they wont know it.
You might not win in a bjj tournament against a BJJ Blackbelt, Iv submited a fighter who was a blackbelt in bjj, from the gracie camp. A blackbelt and the average local gym is like a whitebelt from the gracie camp. Its where it comes from that makes the belt meaning full. You dont need to be a bjj, to tumble and submit. You dont need to be a boxer to fight, it just the way it is.
There are always braggarts who think themselves clever. They say of other boxing that at one glance they know it. They dont realise that while at one glance they knew it, if they look again they wont know it.
I joined this discussion with one purpose; to debunk Homoplata's view of belting. I belted in TKD many years ago and have friends that have belted in BJJ. We have trained together for years. We have added Muay T, Judo & MMA to our arsenal. We have competed in competitions and either knocked out or submitted every opponent. None of us have belted since the beginning. We have beaten many belted opponents. Statements such as yours belittle the sport and cheapen the arts. It truly is the level at which a person performs that measures their success. It is definitley not their clothing!
I am a current MMA competitor.I am planning on going pro in the next few months. I am not sure what it is you were asking other than that,infact,I am almost sure U were using this to advertise a school or venue or something so I will do the same! I train @ "Your MaMA's House" MMA gym.Any1 looking to train MMA in the West Knoxville or Powell area call or text me@ (865)710-4079 or check us out @
myspace.com/timmkitts
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks