Quote:
Originally Posted by DJColdfusion
Why call it Judo when Maeda called it Jiu-Jitsu and in fact so did Kano in the early years? I appreciate your opinion; however, even if it was Judo (which it isn't and if you truly researched the art you would understand that) why would anyone change the name that the art was given by Maeda and adopted by Carlos Gracie Sr. before he began to teach his brothers???
|
the Brazilian Judo thing was just an aside, it makes no difference to me if they prefer to call it jiu-jitsu.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DJColdfusion
[1] Or, more accurately, the techniques of JJJ can be found in their modified forms in Judo.
|
absolutely right, i phrased that poorly.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DJColdfusion
Additionally, just because one art has grown out of another art does not mean that the child art is lacking or a lesser art in some way. Is Judo a pale shadow of JJJ? No. Is Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu a pale shadow of Judo? No.
|
it seems that you
want me to make this assertion so you can have something to argue against when i've explicitly stated several times i believe no such thing. the statements Tanto or i have made about judo newaza and bjj are in no way shape or form derogatory toward bjj.