Best combination of arts.

[bvermillion]

I personally think well taught traditional hapkido is one of the most rounded self defense arts. I stress well taught and traditional. There is no aspect left out of the hapkido I am currently studying. We cover weapons:cane, staff, knife, stick, and rope. Grappling: the grappling isn't the greatest we learn basic simple techniques, standup grappling in hapkido is the best in my opinion, Striking: isn't as good as boxing of muay thai but is just as good as any traditional martial art. No other martial art in my opinion covers all of these aspects as well as hapkido.

[thaibxr]

Im not to fermiliar with hopkido but muay thais clinch I concider to be some of the best stand up grappling what is involved with hopkidos grappling

[manofleisure]

Originally Posted by Tom Yum

No offense, but I don't understand why you ask for which style is best, when you could easily get up, visit a school, try it out and see for yourself. There are alot of great gyms and great instructors out there.

Don't waste time debating here. Do it for real.

I am currently enrolled in a martial art.

Also I thought the reason for forums were to discuss subjects,voice opinions,and get a heads up on information one wouldn't know much about?

[Cain]

what about krav maga and shootfighting.. and working in a high risk job.. :P like i do..

[manofleisure]

The little I saw on some video clips it seemed to be a very good straight up, mix it up, whoop ass art to get into.

However the techniques for certain situations seem to be suspect if they were actually applied in the certain situation they are called upon to defend.

go to the website and look at some of the video clips,I wouldn't count on those techniques for gun defenses, knife, et cetra.

[darrianation]

Originally Posted by Cain

what about krav maga and shootfighting.. and working in a high risk job.. :P like i do..

Hmmmmm…..I like Krav Maga for the most part (there are some weapons disarms I am not fond of).

How about Modern combatives with defensive/tactical knife and firearms, Vale Tudo, Arnis, and maybe a little Krav Maga defenses thrown in?

[manofleisure]

Originally Posted by darrianation

Hmmmmm…..I like Krav Maga for the most part (there are some weapons disarms I am not fond of).

How about Modern combatives with defensive/tactical knife and firearms, Vale Tudo, Arnis, and maybe a little Krav Maga defenses thrown in?

You might have a winner there darrianation.

[crouton]

Originally Posted by bvermillion

I personally think well taught traditional hapkido is one of the most rounded self defense arts. I stress well taught and traditional. There is no aspect left out of the hapkido I am currently studying. We cover weapons:cane, staff, knife, stick, and rope. Grappling: the grappling isn't the greatest we learn basic simple techniques, standup grappling in hapkido is the best in my opinion, Striking: isn't as good as boxing of muay thai but is just as good as any traditional martial art. No other martial art in my opinion covers all of these aspects as well as hapkido.

bvermillion, you should check out vee arnis jitsu. they definitely cover it all and make it very effective while being realistic.

[bvermillion]

Originally Posted by crouton

bvermillion, you should check out vee arnis jitsu. they definitely cover it all and make it very effective while being realistic.

I wont argue the effectiveness of vee arnis jitsu because I have no experience with it. It may be every bit as effective as you say. But I do know it isn't readily available to most people. And isn't as widespread as hapkido.

[Tom Yum]

Originally Posted by bvermillion

I wont argue the effectiveness of vee arnis jitsu because I have no experience with it. It may be every bit as effective as you say. But I do know it isn't readily available to most people. And isn't as widespread as hapkido.

I think Hapkido is a great martial art for self-defense considering it is a traditional martial art.

'Yu Sul' , 'Nak bub' are allmost identical to many basic judo techniques (Nak bub are actually break falls).

'Kwan Jel Sul' , 'kyuk too ki' are in line with aikijutsu/Japanese Jujitsu standup grappling and joint locking.

Kicking techniques are more like Tang Soo Do rather than Tae Kwon Do. More of an emphasis on thrust rather than snap. For example, the round kick has more hip turn over than the TKD round kick but not the same amount of snap. The side kick chambers and thrusts rather than coming up and in. Spin kicks are thrown with the leg slightly bent and again use hip turnover, wheras TKD pivot and snap the heel (more like a hook kick). TKD kicks are faster but not harder than TSD/HKD kicking.

There are sets of 5-6 low kicking techniques with different techniques and targets, each with different targets so snap kicks won't cut it. In sparring with kicks above the waste however, TKD can more likely land first.

[Tom Yum]

Originally Posted by manofleisure

I am currently enrolled in a martial art.

My apologies.

Too often, people want to know what the best martial art is without seeing for things for themselves, there likes/abilities or know what excercise will improve their technique.

There's no right answer for the first part. However, nothing beats frequent practice and good coaching for the second part.

There's a guy on here who has practiced Hsing-Yi/Bagua/Taijiquan (internal gong fu) and works as a doorman at an establishment and trains with other MA-ists...

Others have invested time in Judo & Karate and can hold their own against skilled fighters....

Still some train in several Reality Based Self Defense methods with both empty hands and modern weapons and it has saved their butts....

Yet others have sweated their @sses off pounding pads, mitts & sparring while grappling and can take a licking and keep on ticking....

No such thing as all around best combination of arts, just hard working/well-rounded MA ists.

[sirmattu]

i would have to say a good combination would be tae kwon do, judo and some sort of ma with strong hand tecs. maybe even just boxing. this covers all the fundamentals.

[Uncle Corny]

Originally Posted by Kensh0

Right now I'm doing Judo and Muay Thai-I think this is an effective combination as most fights end up from striking to a grappling contest, plus training for them is intense and as realistic as you can get for real combat/fighting situations.

i disagree.

[Uncle Corny]

if you're really into the whole caste system of ego inflation with belts and levels, i'd say go for russian systema, israeli krav maga, and tekkenryu jujutsu.

[sirmattu]

Originally Posted by Uncle Corny

if you're really into the whole caste system of ego inflation with belts and levels, i'd say go for russian systema, israeli krav maga, and tekkenryu jujutsu.

and whys that so much better?