Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

MT: Boundary Pushing

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • MT: Boundary Pushing

    Boundary Pushing By Ange - Mon, 26 Nov 2007 07:28:32 GMT

    =========

    Hi all
    Boundary Pushing - isn't that what we all do when we practice our particular Martial Art?
    Of course! We push our bodies physically as well as mentally and love every minute of it, Right?
    Well 11 weeks ago, I was coming up to grading for 3rd Gup, and thats quite a big deal for this overweight 47yr old women. Mentally I can do anything! You go girl, I can hear people say.
    We were practicing gaining extra distance with our stances. Simple and easy? Yep!
    Nope - my toes gripped (too much) our beautiful floor, my foot pronated completely forward and outwards and apparently I did the most magnificent land and roll anyone had seen.
    Out of 10, I would score the pain in my foot a 15. I didn't say a thing, I didn't even swear. It took all my effort to stay conscious. I also remember hearing the crack.
    The upshot of this was I had smashed 4 metatarsals (bones behind the toe bones) and also the 3 cuboids (behind the metatarsals). I finally had to fly to Brisbane (Oz) from Darwin where I live = 4.5 hrs flying for surgery. It is now 6 weeks since surgery and I have lots and lots of hardware in my foot, and will not be able to go back to SBD for at least 12 months, so my Dan Shim Ssa will be two and a half years away instead of 18 months.
    The moral of this - Why was I trying to emulate my 6ft4, 27yr young Sa Dan Instructor, when I am 5ft4 47yr old overweight 4th Gup?
    Gee this sound bitter doesn't it? I am frustrated as hell hopping around on crutches or scooting around in a wheelchair, but most of all I am frustrated at not being able to do the thing I love - Karate. I have reflected on the accident though and in hindsight I probably would have done the same thing anyway.
    I wonder whether (those of us that are mature aged women) we should be trying to emulate the adonis instructors or does/should realism and acknowledgement of our capabilities come into play?
    What do you all think?
    Ciao
    One Leg Angela


    Read More ... or click reply below.
    ------------------------------
    MartialTalk.com Post Bot - Women's Self-Defense Feed

  • #2
    ID personally be back in the dojo/gym in plaster cast and getting on with it. modify stance etc and do it.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by Ghost View Post
      ID personally be back in the dojo/gym in plaster cast and getting on with it. modify stance etc and do it.

      LOL!!! NEVER modify technique to compensate for injury! you only tear up more!


      But yeah, I am a competitive cuss, I want to do things just as good and fast and high as the person next to me, head to head - and many times it is a teen, young adult with more flexibility and the likes then my old bod...

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by GranFire View Post
        LOL!!! NEVER modify technique to compensate for injury! you only tear up more!


        But yeah, I am a competitive cuss, I want to do things just as good and fast and high as the person next to me, head to head - and many times it is a teen, young adult with more flexibility and the likes then my old bod...
        Why not modify technique, do people fall apart if you do something slightly different.

        If that were true then only fully able bodied people could do martial arts. thats not the case.

        Comment


        • #5
          no, not if it is a condition that is supposed to heal.

          You modify you put undue stress on other parts of the body.

          Of course, some conditions are worse then others: I learned how to do a twist kick rather nicely when I had a huge wart removed from my heel...not being able to stand on it for 2 days after treatment, it was about the only kick I could practice at home when the urge struck (and it has been a while, the kick got rusty - and no, I am not gonna have the Doc carve up my foot again just so I can have a nice twist kick! )

          Comment


          • #6
            You can modify your training technique for sure, but you shouldn't start morphing the actual moves, that just makes bad habits. Example: I've trained people in wheelchairs on different kinds of hand techniques, they can also sometimes grapple. But if the doc. says don't put weight on it, it's better to choke it down than be all crippled and in pain forever.

            Comment

            Working...
            X