Roofing shingle choice

[gisselletdean]

I was reading a short book on asphalt shingles called Roofing Ripoff. The author seems to have a pretty good knowledge of home building. He compared how shingles were made many decades ago with how they are made today. Basically less asphalt. The shingles weigh less. And even though you may get a long warranty it's typically only for shingle manufacturing defects.

The net is shingles made today even though they are fiberglass, last about 1/2 as long as shingles made several decades ago.

To net things out, if you want a shingle to last a really long time you need one made with SBS. Several shingle companies have an SBS shingle. But it's more expensive.

Has anyone looked into this and decided on a shingle made with SBS? GAF sells the Timberline ArmorShield II.

Some may say if it lasts 10 years I will be in another house.

[capabilitieso]

I understand many makers took the copper out of the roofing granules or lessened it causing the algae and roof stains you see everywhere now.

[OliverShultz]

I’ve definitely noticed the difference in the quality of shingles over the years. When I had my roof redone, I was concerned about longevity, so I opted for shingles made with SBS. I went with a premium brand, and while it was a bit more expensive upfront, I feel better knowing it’s more durable. The roofing company I worked with, Dakzorg, was really helpful in guiding me through the options. They explained how SBS shingles can handle harsher weather and last longer. I’d recommend doing some research, but if you’re planning to stay in your home for the long haul, it could be a smart investment!