Very Interesting Question

[kingoftheforest]

If he is a trained fighter and you have no experience sneaking up on people than using the gun may be a little hard depending on how close you have to get. Unless you can get him in his sleep.

I'm gonna go with 20+ years of training in my art.

[npk9]

I would rather have a gun.

20+ years of training. . . whatever.. . how many people do you know have 20+ years of training and they still amount to nothing.

[angacam]

good technical question i guess. I'd rather have 20+ years of experience, personally I DON'T like guns and would take a knife over a gun anyday.

Are you Italian?

[wsdddoa012]

response

good technical question i guess. I'd rather have 20+ years of experience, personally I DON'T like guns and would take a knife over a gun anyday.

[DickHardman]

i already answered this question.....

refer to the original thread.....

http://www.defend.net/deluxeforums/showthread.php?t=23951&highlight=marky+mark%27

i would rather have a us marines supercobra attack chopper with marky mark as my copilot so i could fly off the island while marky mark mans the weapons systems. either i will kill the martial artist with the cobras nose mounted gatling attached to my head set and eyepiece or marky will kill the martial artist with a guided missile.

[Tom Yum]

(Then I'd hope Ginger and Mary Ann would show up!!)

That's a hunger-heat-induced hallucination, bro...what you think are Giner and Mary Ann are really a palm tree and a smelly camel.

[kwai chang pain]

I'd rather defeat the opponent in hand to hand, then pistol whip him, then shoot him.

(Then I'd hope Ginger and Mary Ann would show up!!)

[LightHevyWeight]

mmmmm... smart

[Tom Yum]

Keep it simple: use the pistol.

[LightHevyWeight]

hmmm, i dont know man. Lets say hes not speciallized in knife/gun disarms. Hes a martial artist, a 1st dan guy. NOW what would your choice be? :P

-Really, a Bruce Lee movie? Unfortunattely I never saw any of his movies. I read this question in one of the posts.

[Tom Yum]

hmmm i dunno about that, dont confuse the question man :P

in this sitiuation would you lik to be a skilled martial artist or would you rather shoot or stab a guy?

Not trying to confuse the question, but what if the dude on the island knows the island like the back of his hand, is really good with camoflauge/concealment and specializes in knife-gun disarms?

PS - your scenario sounds alot like a plot from a certain Bruce Lee movie...

[LightHevyWeight]

lool Angacam, Good Choice

[angacam]

Cool, shoot him then fight him. LOL, you get more from a kind word and a gun than from just a kind word.

[LightHevyWeight]

lool good choice angacam, but as for me, id like to fight him

[angacam]

Shoot the bugger!