Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Self Preservation or MMA

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Self Preservation or MMA

    In Self Preservation training the fight exsists for the fighter. In Mixed Martial Arts the fighter exsists for the fight. In Self Preservation the fighter fights because he has to. In MMA the fighter fights because he wants to.

    We all understand the nature of combat but the application of that understanding is where we differ, quite dramaticlly. Throughout the centuries people have laid out their views regarding the underlying principles of self defense both theoretically and practically. Modern practitioners have tried to demonstrate, in a practical way, the essentials of the more recent developments in functional tactics and training methods. This has been beneficial to all who observe the trends and implement the usefull additions of various schools of thought. We must be aware of and beware of the “halo effect” (the beleif that any change is a good change).

    MMA, though important and positive, is not the pinnacle of current martial ideology. It lacks the potential for response to higher threat levels which are by no means out of the realm of probability in todays world. Threats regarding firearms, weapons, multiple attackers, home invasion and the like are not on the agenda of MMA. Striking, clinch and ground fighting are of great value and are areas that must be trained, understood and developed. From there, pre fight psychology, OC Spray, firearms, impact weapons, white light, bladed weapons and more must become part of the training. Spending some of your valuable training time on each of these areas becomes a normal part of your routine. Gaining a degree of proficiency in these areas is what self Preservation is all about.

    MMA is geared toward glory. Self Preservation is geared toward avoiding violence. MMA operates in a ring. Self Preservation operates in a hallway or a living room at 2:00am. MMA is about winning. Self Preservation is about escaping.

    In my opinion, progessive methods should include physical tactics and psycological applications but should ignore the spiritual altogether. A practitioner must be prepared to endure long periods of physical and mental concentration and focus. Training is fun but also very serious. Tacking on some spiritual mysticism to muddy the waters is adding insult to training injury. Far to often there is a mystic guru who everyone can sit around and talk about. Circular logic can be fun but it is generally a distraction.

    Self Preservation is concerned with the individual and not the organization or group. Self Preservation is not concerned with figure heads and hero worship. Self Preservation strives to impose peace.

    Self Preservation exsists somewhere between tight black shorts and camaflauge pants.

    I’d still rather see someone do MMA instead of traditional martial arts any day. I just question peoples motives when they train. Do you exsist for the fight or does the fight exsist for you.

    Demi


  • #2
    good post, few good points raised.

    Comment


    • #3
      Neither Demi,
      I don't compete MMA, and I stopped training for self defense years ago. I got tired of simulating assaults etc. It just wasn't for me. I train for fun mostly. I get a charge on working on increasing my performance level. That's enough for me. I agree with you about the spiritual aspect. I found that the spiritual, philosophy, mental aspects etc. aren't separate from training. What I mean is that the philosophy happens because of the training not the other way around. To separate the two is to create a false duallity that doesn't exist. Oops! I hope I'm not getting to philosophical.
      I know alot of people who fight MMA and most of them do it because they enjoy testing their techniques in a arena. Most of them don't care much about the self defense aspect of their techniques. MMA is a sport. Does it have any self defense value? Of course it does. Is it the best training for self defense? I won't argue that one. I don't question their motives as you do. A MMA guy does try to win, but it is not about winning as you state. Most MMA guys I know don't put much emphasis on winning or losing. They really don't. They are really focussing on improving their performance. Not their performance in a street brawl, but their performance in the arena that they train for. They like MMA because they can test their techniques real time. They don't have to rely on simulations and make believe situations to test their techniques. They get instant validation on the effectiveness of their techniques. There is great comfort in that and the MMA athlete doesn't have to rely so much on the experience of others but can test everything out in their own lab.

      Comment


      • #4
        I think mma is one of the best in self defense but it should be combined with the phsycological aspect of a fight as well as weapons and awareness. MMA fighters like the Gracies realize this and have self defense against weapons in bjj as long with a few pre-emptive strikes. Relson also has something on groundfighting with multiple opponents and Rickson does a simulation in which he is in one room with a door and two people are blocking it and he tries to escape.

        Comment


        • #5
          Demi,
          Was this just a diatribe or do you wish to actually discuss the topic? I dislike when people post their grand philosophies all over the web and don't bother to back them up with actual discussion.

          Comment


          • #6
            Demi,

            I have been saying these things for years and have made at least a hundred posts in this forum alone on the subject. I am glad to read your post. By the way you put more eloquently then I have.

            Comment


            • #7
              good post.....

              Comment

              Working...
              X