If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Originally posted by Szczepankiewicz Getting back to debate and philosophize and what Terry and I were going back and forth on.
Our curriculum is set up in four major categories. One is concerned chiefly with strategy, tactics, principles and exercise. The other three deal with transportation, striking, and grappling. So over 75% of what we learn deals with doing, more so if you count the exercises.
For any given technique you spend, say, about 10% of your time taking notes, learning, pondering, possibly discussing, and eventually teaching said technique. The other 90-95 percent of your time is spent executing, practicing, improving your technique. Training your body to know the technique without knowing it at all.
So Terry is absolutely right, as all who have trained will recognize, that experience is very important. Train, train, and then train some more.
However, without the philosophy to guide your training, without direction your efforts may well be misguided. Look at all those people working soooo hard in the mcdojo. They work so hard for so long and are often times worse off than when they began.
A balanced perspective well made, Szczepankiewicz. No disagreement here.
Interestingly enough, on most I've been banned just for disagreeing with the fasionable views they all share with each other. Its like "come and discuss this, but you must agree with us".
Okay, Br Thai, you're officially sitebanned. (*chuckle*) Seriously, though, poking a little fun isn't gonna harm anyone. Neither will disagreement. The farther I got into this particular dialogue with spanky it emerged that spanky and I had the kind of non-disagreement that is akin to looking at the same glass half-full vs. half-empty. I thought that his final statement was more balanced than what I had made. So I learned something.
I have exercised the right to moderate some of your posts when you got into long running exchanged of ad honymym attacks with people like ramus. The reason is that too much of this drives people away that are actually looking to learn about martial arts.
At the same time I also cut people like crazyjoe380 and you some slack because you make (and I know some might disagree with this) positive contributions. Albeit on rare occasions.
That slack goes away when, like Crouchtig, people start posting nothing but disruptive garbage. Especially if it starts going racist, sexist & anti-semitic just to get attention, which has happened a couple of times on this forum.
Comment