I was very tired when I wrote the above post, my apologies for rambling . . . to paraphrase "Yes, I do think BJJ is an effective form of selfdefense".
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
BJJ Street effectiveness?
Collapse
X
-
Resident Groaner
- Jun 2003
- 2118
-
There are no second chances.
“Anyone can give up, it's the easiest thing in the world to do. But to hold it together when everyone else would understand if you fell apart, that's true strength.”
Originally posted by Tom YumGhost, you are like rogue from x-men but with a willy.
*drools*
-
Resident Groaner
- Jun 2003
- 2118
-
There are no second chances.
“Anyone can give up, it's the easiest thing in the world to do. But to hold it together when everyone else would understand if you fell apart, that's true strength.”
Originally posted by Tom YumGhost, you are like rogue from x-men but with a willy.
*drools*
-
A friend of mine on another forum had an opportunity to hang out with Relson (Gracie) one day...
He related this story you might find of interest...
(or not?)
Relson Gracie was in the store a few months ago.
He was in town for a seminar and came by with an employee who attended, to shoot some full auto guns. He was looking around the store and we started chatting, VERY cool guy (the bad asses usually are) and one of the guys there had me show him the Karambit in action. Afterward, he made the comment that "if you have a knife or gun, Jiu-Jitsu not work" which is not the mindset of many of the BJJ guys I have rolled with.
...
*****
Keep it real gentlemen...
most respectfully,
~RG.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Tant01 View PostA friend of mine on another forum had an opportunity to hang out with Relson (Gracie) one day...
He related this story you might find of interest...
(or not?)
Relson Gracie was in the store a few months ago.
He was in town for a seminar and came by with an employee who attended, to shoot some full auto guns. He was looking around the store and we started chatting, VERY cool guy (the bad asses usually are) and one of the guys there had me show him the Karambit in action. Afterward, he made the comment that "if you have a knife or gun, Jiu-Jitsu not work" which is not the mindset of many of the BJJ guys I have rolled with.
...
*****
Keep it real gentlemen...
most respectfully,
~RG.
Honestly, not the kind of stuff I've heard from Relson . . . soirry, but I honestly doubt that ever happened.
Comment
-
Well said
DJColdfusion is right on track....street defense/preservation is not about coming out unscathed, it's about coming out. Talk to the well trained Filipino guys and there is an acceptance of injury to "win a knife fight", well trained boxers know there will be contact back in all encounters, BJJ guys know that outdoor grappling sucks dirty donkey D!ck but is a favorable alternative to getting "a mudhole stomped in your face" (DMX baby). No one wants to face multiple opponents, movie heroism be damned, and certainly when presented with the daunting task of facing said group even a wallpaper paste eating retard knows the ground is the last place you "Want to be", but better to be prepared than destroyed before you even get started!!!!
Comment
-
I owe Tant01 an apology. (This is it) I did not mean to infer dishonesty in my post that referenced his Relson story. I just don't believe Relson ever said it.
Whether it was the language barrier or someone just misunderstood someone else . . . I don't know.
I honestly just don't think it happened.
Comment
-
Originally posted by bodhisattva View PostThat scene had two pro fighters going at it.
When a pro is against a pro, its a lot harder to pull off some of the moves.
That's like watching a pro boxing match and saying "They hit each other nonstop for 10 rounds and at the end they were still standing. Are you certain boxing is effective for self defense?"
BJJ is important even if you don't want to be on the ground. If a stand up fighter doesn't have good ground skills, he is going to get stuck on the ground (and unable to get up off the grounda nd back on his feet) a lot.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Grixti View PostAnyone have some detailed views on this subject?!
I was watching ultimate fighter on Bravo (upcoming ultimate fighters competing to fight in the UFC) and these two guys ended up having a scap in the house that all the fighters were staying in. I have to admit it was the most technical street fight i had ever seen. At one point one guy got the other in an arm bar but just got his head smashed on the concrete when he was lifted up and slammed down.
My point here is that BJJ might not be the best style for the street as your most likely going to be fighting on concrete and a lot of the time fighting more than one person. If you get someone in a submission you could either get slammed or get your head kicked in by the guys mate.
Might it be better to learn wrestling?
Comment
-
Registered User
- Jul 2004
- 1865
-
"a few User CP's that are pretty significant ones(like a BoarSpear or SamuraiGuy one). " - GracieHunter
I choke people, I dont poke people. -- Me
Were you born to resist or be abused? I swear I'll never give in, I refuse. -- Foo Fighters
I want a girl that spends more time on her back than Royce Gracie.
I'll knee you in the face like your name was Josh Koschek -- Me
Originally posted by Liberty View PostAny hope for a clip of this one!
The guy locked up the armbar, and was slowly picked up and bounced a few times, both werent trying to hurt each other, I think it may have played out differently if the guy applying the armbar decided to shoot his hips up and crank it as hard as he could, ala royce gracie in the early UFC's (I know he broke at least one arm).
Theres always the underhook of the leg which prevents slams, and along with the underhooking the leg the pendulum sweep that comes from it.
Dont know why no one ever does that in MMA, maybe they want to get Arona'd?
Comment
-
Found the Clip: You need to log on cos its an over 18. Ill try and put it in my post.
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4rznkMqCN0[/YOUTUBE]
You can see this guys holds werent all that effective because he got slammed into a few obsticals. But obviously the other fighter was very strong and skilled and if he got a normal guy into an arm-bar it might of even got broken.
But watching it back i can see how his BJJ did help him, even if he did get slammed twice he managed to keep the other guy away from just purely pounding on his face.
Good fight though, nice to see two UFC fighters go at it without a ref.
Enjoy.
Comment
Comment