MT vs. SANSHOU

[Toudiyama[NL]]

no....

boxing is better than karate, why????

cause the karate punch, after they punch they withdraw their fist and put their fist unto their waist..... while boxers dont put their fist unto their waist so they have time to deliver an immediate speed punch although both of them are telegraphic

Ahh the layman is talking again

The karatepunch isn't retracted to the waist but in front of the chest, the wrist protects the solar plexus

Annd again you evade the point, the point being that you first claim to be better than others because they do straitline punches and then you claim you are better then others because You do straitline strikes

I didn't say Karate was better than boxing
I say that according to your reasoning karate is better because it has straitline punches
you think because you read some books that in a fight karatepunches travel from the waist, the elbow is positioned at the side of the waistline but the position of the hand depends on the fighting distance, the closer the higher

MT and Boxing telegaph the punches...maybe but then you react to that and catch the next one on you chin
BTW what's so telegraphic about a right cross? or a left jab? a right strait? ( hey, strait )
You base your theories on one punch of other arts and on top of that you have very limited knowledge about those

[retired]

sherwinc how can you say that boxing & MT telegraph a strike?

If i throw a dummy left body punch at you fast then while your reacting with your wax on wax off im already following up with hard right elbow at your face which even at your hit ratio would destroy you as you have let me hit you once which is enough for my superior power.

Do you really think that a Karate guy would stand there in a deep stance with his hands down by his waist on the street?

Have you ever seen any advanced MT moves?

How can you boast about your superior kungfu yet give in to wingchun?

You said "Note:
all 22 strikes are all targeted to 108 death cavities, which means, it will not only lead you to KO but an instant death if done properly.......

example:
eyes, adam's apple, groin, kneecap, windpipe, etc...."

If you can do this so easilly on the street how do you know what art the other guy has practiced & will you like most people with big mouths just fall apart when confronted by a total looney headcase on the street or anyone with a good chin.

You speak of kicking someone in the groin but most arts have defence for this.

Take my advice.......stop reading & actually go to a decent MT club for a shock when you challenge them.

[Tom Yum]

Take my advice.......stop reading & actually go to a decent MT club for a shock when you challenge them.

Like he's going to shatter his own style that easily

[retired]

sherwinwc download these just to see what your missing in your art :

http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/TOC.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch1.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch2.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch3.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch4.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch5.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch6.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch7.pdf

You need Adobe Reader to view.

And shock Horror we actually have defensive & destructive moves like you .

[shootodog]

in the heart of Iloilo City. City Boy takon ya bay

nice place to visit?

Taoist Based KungFu will never defeat any Shaolin Based KungFu such as NgoChoKun and WingChun......

hmmm...

[shootodog]

back on track, does the original post question perhaps pertain to cung le?

[retired]

Hmmm no reply to me?........i wonder if he downloaded those files & run off with his tail between his legs after realising what a cock-up he's made.

[sherwinc]

nice place to visit?



hmmm...

polluted and full of waste papers on the streets, since some of the government is corrupt hehehe

i have a question:

what is really important (winning in actual fights)
is it STRENGTH(POWER) or TECHNIQUE??????

cause i research plenty of sources..... many prefers TECHNIQUES, and many prefers STRENGTH(or Power)

[sherwinc]

sherwinwc download these just to see what your missing in your art :

http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/TOC.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch1.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch2.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch3.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch4.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch5.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch6.pdf
http://www.shaolin.ee/pdf/Ch7.pdf

You need Adobe Reader to view.

And shock Horror we actually have defensive & destructive moves like you .

I'm still reading, this is one of the best documents regarding Muay Thai informations.....

[shootodog]

polluted and full of waste papers on the streets, since some of the government is corrupt hehehe

i have a question:

what is really important (winning in actual fights)
is it STRENGTH(POWER) or TECHNIQUE??????

cause i research plenty of sources..... many prefers TECHNIQUES, and many prefers STRENGTH(or Power)

the answer is: whatever works. being able to walk away is the best feeling there is.

pare, kung puro porma lang, supot din! (dude, if it's all forms no substance, it still sucks). pretty wins pagaents, not fights.

[Vio]

MT is dangerous you can break your shin easily. I have video evidence!!! to prove

[Tom Yum]

MT is dangerous you can break your shin easily. I have video evidence!!! to prove

That video clip has been around the block and back (no analogies please).

Thanks

[Tom Yum]

my first blow is a very illegal and a foul
GET MY POINT????????

Sherwinc remembers giving his first blow. You'd figure with legalized prostitution it would be legal there..jj

[HuSanYan]

MT is dangerous you can break your shin easily. I have video evidence!!! to prove

Vio, i have just came back into this thread and seen the above links which I am now downloading, they are quite big some of these pdf's, HuSanYan shall read and get back to y'all in this thread as i have some recent training aspects (MT & Boxing) I would like to add.
Vio, as a man in my mid thirties, I have some concerns about my poor old shins and I think your comment is fair.

I will comment tomorrow after spending some time reading the above pdf's.

bye for now folks

NB, folks, friends and loathers of HuSanYan, I will be entering the UFC soon and will keep the boards informed

[Boxiados]

Hai! You're wrong!
Do you know that Kungfu Fighter through Shansou/Sanda won several times at "KUNGFU VS MUAY THAY" Event both in China and/or Thailand? You should learn more deeply before you give your recommendation! Thanks.

Bull shit man!
I'ven ever seen or heard of Sanshou/Sanda beating Thai fighters...